A week ago, I saw a huge “kerfuffle” erupt over the comment thread of a LitRPG review where the term ‘Male Power Fantasy’ was introduced to the conversation. ‘Male power fantasy’ is a tricky term that’s used both as a necessary caution to established authors, but also a pejorative term for those who just want to sling mud and bait aggro. As with most divisive terms such as this, it’s easy to be interpreted in a myriad of different ways due to passive aggression but I’d like to weigh in on the narrative issues perpetuated by Power Fantasies for sake of establishing why I’ve made the decisions I’ve made with what will hopefully be my upcoming SciFan magazine serial: Immersion.
This is a personal and biased opinion, but while I don’t believe Male Power Fantasies are harmful for merit of just existing, the problem that I have with them is that I’ve never really found them to say anything differently from one story to the next. Power Fantasy stories don’t seem to be told by an author so much as being retold over and over.
The problem with Power Fantasies isn’t that they exist. because I totally understand and appreciate formulaic stories which are created for the sole purpose of delivering essentially the same payoff every iteration. I am a fan of Marvel Movies and I can tell you exactly what equation they follow and slowly weep like a small child since the New Spider-man movie illustrates this equation without a hint of an attempt to hide it- but I will do my best to maintain my composure long enough to finish writing this post.*
The problem, once again in my biased opinion #disclaimer, is that the Power Fantasy MC has the most agency out of any NPC (or sometimes even other player characters) and the writer has consolidated the roles of multiple characters into the MC to the point where MC now monopolizes all the force of will in this story’s universe.
The reason why I’m being so specific is that, funnily enough, I would say that LitRPG is the genre where Monopolization is MOST NOTICEABLE. Not because of “Gamergate”, “SJWs”, “Women”, or “Fake LitRPG Authors posing as Reviewers to get rich?????” but because the authors will painstakingly establish a meta... only for their MCs to BREAK it!
Once again, for sake of disclaimer. I am not intending to come off as cruel or harsh, I’m relaying exactly what happens in many stories according to negative public reviews. Also, on a mechanical level I understand what happening with the author. They see that they’re character is falling into a repetitive funk because he’s alone or MVP of the team so they have to immediately change approaches for sake of the health of their storyline.
How often have we seen MCs who conveniently switch classes, gain abilities they aren’t intended to have, or completely/permanently invalidate their own weaknesses through necessity of the plot rather than the ingenuity of their own quick thinking for that one-off scenario?
The list goes on but I’m not trying to be mean, so I’ll cut it there.
This isn’t a problem with gender equality and it isn’t even a problem restricted to one gender (Mary Sues are just as guilty but in LitRPG they are woefully outnumbered so this complaint doesn’t occur as frequently- but it does occur).
The reason it is a problem to have an Power Fantasy MC in LitRPG is because:
1) These are traits or activities which others characters could be doing while your character continues to do their own thing! Your character can be as strong as you want with whatever skill you choose and bang as many people as you deem appropriate but if they’re doing everything perfectly all alone it tends to destroy suspense or a sense of peril. There’s a reason Kirk, Spock, and McCoy are different people and have different fanbases: together they’d be the worst Gary Stu imaginable but separately they are memorable and ICONIC. More so, the gap of morals/temperaments between them actually sells their individual characteristics that much more!
2) The tutorial sections explaining game mechanics or exhibiting stat sheets are usually daggers in the eyes of people who aren’t into LitRPG because they aren’t predisposed to the author stopping the events of the story just to tell them everything they need to know about the game before the MC can go about their adventure. I know it’s a mark against an author to cater to readers who aren’t part of our ‘core audience’ but that doesn’t mean that we can’t try and take up a challenge for sake of changing up the writing meta a little. Something as simple as having another person for the MC to bounce ideas off of or instruct the MC would be welcome as opposed to unnatural vocal narration from the MC on top of usually sufficient narration from the author.
3) Other characters can reinforce mythos more reliably than the readers simply being told by the author why a power is useful, a villain is scary, or a weapon is meta/garbage. I think a lot of people cite “anime” as a huge turnoff when it comes to LitRPG but I believe that the intention is positive, it’s just that authors aren’t taking the correct lessons from anime. That sounds crazy but please hear me out!
For instance, a lot of Anime comes from Manga, or comics for those who don’t know. The comics are obviously still-frames depicting motion. In many early cases with martial arts manga, the artists and writers would rely on a side-lined character to narrate to the readers exactly what was going on in the panels so that the reader would know how to interpret the image. When the Manga is adapted to Anime this convention stuck because this side-line narration helps to “sell” the gravity of a fight, but admittedly in today’s anime it’s a little unnecessary since we can see the fight for ourselves. The side-line narrator is just a trope that has become synonymous with martial arts anime and they are included because it’s simply a part of the story at this point! And I love that!
In LitRPG though, this convention of side-line narration is born anew since we not only sometimes require context for what’s happening on the printed page, but there’s often game meta associated with what’s happening as well. Having a teammate who can convey this would be a great workaround if you want to avoid plot dumping a lot of chunks of text to readers. Combine this with the appropriate characterization or set precedents prior to the fight and the side-line narration can actually sell your game mechanics a lot more than the writer just stating it plainly.
In the spirit of “perspective” discussed in my previous post, here’s an excerpt from the interplay between the ensemble cast in Immersion, a serial I’m hoping to get published in SciFan Magazine. This by no means is a universal solvent that’s meant to be take as a commandment of literature, it’s merely a workaround I had fun developing.
I hope you have fun reading it too, and then I’ll break it down after.
====
Ken hopped back to the control panel and proceeded to initiate the unlocking sequence. He reminded everyone with a hint of aggravation in his tone, “Alright so when I free her, the alarms are going to be triggered and ‘New Player Experience’ or not, reinforcements will most likely be called in due to our collective player rank. From there it’s simple enough: We cheez it through the excavation site and cross the finish line to end the mission.” He added while looking up at nothing in particular, “Does everyone remember what they’re doing?”
Dagny, now comparing the the alien weapons to her own rifle, replied without looking up, “Flanking as usual, easy-peezy.” She added under her breath, “If Rowan can be bothered to join us, anyway.”
Via comms, a Gaelic cadence replied with painstaking focus, “I’m opening my chakras and attaining Nirvanic Enlightenment, dear wife. Just another few minutes and I’ll be there to carry your fine ass across the finish line with time to spare.”
Ken looked into the viewing window of the cryogenic pod again, “And you?”
“I’m sticking with you. If we get separated then I always make a bee-line to you.”
Ken smiled, “Copacetic!”
“So, I know I’m new and all, but you mentioned these New Player Experiences were procedurally generated based on player rank. And you also said that player rank factored in previous game saves from earlier installments for additional perks and challenges. Doesn’t that mean we’re on extra hard difficulty since we’re all coming from previous saves?”
Ken shrugged, “The perks are just randomly assigned abilities or spells from previous games that are discontinued-”
“Until DLC.” Dagny and Rowan added in unison.
“Until DLC.” Ken rolled his eyes and continued, “As far as difficult? It won’t be if we stick to the plan. Dagny’s prioritizing special targets like casters or ranged fighters with her sniper rifle, Rowan’s face-tanking everything within reach and drawing aggro away from the rest of us, and I’m facilitating both of them with my alchemy while escorting you.”
Dagny added with resignation, “Basically, whether we succeed or fail is completely dependent on whether you can keep yourself out of trouble. Don’t screw this up for us, noob.”
Rowan assured calmly, “That’s Dagny’s way of saying that you can count on us to protect you so don’t feel the need to worry about anything other than crossing the finish line!”
Ken added casually, “Besides, we always have Plan X.”
Dagny furrowed her brow upon recalling the so-called ‘Plan X’, “Wait that’s seriously on the table?”
Ken looked back to her with a shrug, “I mailed you the tracking beacon before we left.”
Rowan replied as softly as he could between long, measured breaths, “I missed something, what’s Plan X exactly?”
Dagny struck her rifle onto the ground bayonet-first and leaned against the stock while looking to Ken incredulously, “The one where we use our ship to commit suicide!
Ken indicated via a euphemism before the newbie could ask questions he wasn’t prepared to answer, “Plan X is the one where we bring the finish line to us-”
“Wait we have a ship?”
Ken winced, “Y-yes. I wanted that to be a surprise.”
The smile evident in her voice, she gasped, “Like in Wind Waker?”
Rowan calmly pointed out, “That’s actually an apt descriptor!”
“...Does the ship have a name?”
Rowan muttered, “Here we go-”
Dagny protested, “No, it doesn’t-”
Ken declared proudly as Rowan began to laugh, “We call it: The Antares!”
“That’s so cool!”
Dagny finally shouted, “Okay Everyone shut up! Is no one else freaking out because our contingency plan is something our Quartermaster saw on ‘Rooster Teeth?”
“Youtube wouldn’t lie to me!” Ken retorted with mock-outrage-
The newbie finally blurted, “Okay seriously, I would like to have a body again please.”
Ken turned his attention back to the console, “Right. Sorry Mina.”
===
Mina is the MC stuck in the cryopod waiting for her boyfriend to free her, meanwhile Rowan is off doing something crucial to prepare to Tank for the group and Dagny is clearly not happy to be there. Each of their personalities the relations thereof are established and each are mechanically playing a role to the story while advancing it where it needs to be prior to the main action taking place (an excerpt which I will post in roughly 20 minutes as a payoff for sitting through these posts).
As MC, Mina/Marina asks questions the reader would ask but is clearly enthusiastic to be there. Her excitement and wonder over the gameworld is something I hope will be shared with the reader as they follow her on her journey.
Ken guides her to a very overprotective extent, but proves that while his knowledge of the game may be encyclopedic, he’s also very unreliable in the way of sound logic. That unpredictability could just as easily be a source of safety or danger and there’s no certainty which way that will go. He establishes a sense of peril despite also being a source of comfort.
Rowan positively reaffirms the strategies and personalities he is opposite of. He’s happy to be there, is calm, cool, and competent. He’s their rock and so if he expresses confidence then the reader should feel that he’s trustworthy to lead them the correct path.
Conversely, there’s his wife Dagny. Who while unreasonably negative for her own personal reasons, provides just enough resistance so that characters are given a reason to concisely explain otherwise complicated ideas while she also sells the peril involved on those concise ideas. Due to her blunt nature, characters often respond simplistically or sarcastically, thus removing another layer of unnecessary complexity to those game mechanics and making the exchange more of an illustration of humor than an overwhelming block of exposition being force-fed to you.
As said before, I want Immersion to encapsulate the benefits of perspective and what that affords a team of like-minded people as they slowly begin to drift toward their own personal goals. As foreshadowed in Control Alt Sadit, these people will also be stuck in the game at some point and so that interpersonal dynamic will also have to withstand the test of pressure as they are forced to work together to make sense of a procedurally generated universe where science fiction and fantasy co-exist.
And now for the payoff to this horribly long post I’m steadily editing down as we continue into the latter half of our hour. Big thanks to Blaise for not beating me with a sock full of batteries yet. In 10 minutes I’ll include an action packed preview for the upcoming Serial Immersion followed by our send off post to close out the hour.
Thanks everyone!
No comments:
Post a Comment