Saturday, April 8, 2017

Building Rapport with Villains: The Tragedy of Impasse

 
One thing that has always struck me as a little off about the depiction of villains in mainstream media is that they’re often defined by their actions, by the ways they are a foil to the protagonist of the story, or ignored in favor of the actors who portray them. It’s very seldom that they are depicted to the audience as genuinely endearing or even trustworthy.
In the universe of Eidolon, we’ve been introduced to one villain in the way of Sadit who genuinely chooses to do things that he knows on some level are wrong in exchange for personal enrichment. Depending on who is reading the story, what Sadit is after will be interpreted differently. The interpretations are all valid, but my core intention was to play with a writing mechanic I don’t see utilize that often.
I’m not sure what the academic term for the mechanic is, but I refer to it as “Building Rapport”.
In the previous post, I touched on the idea that the crucial factor of Sadit’s own motivations was that he was emotionally disconnected from his family. But on a more mechanical level, by understanding where he’s coming from, it gives weight to the actions he takes to get where he’s going. You don’t have to come from an emotionally distant family to relate with him, you just have to see what he had to deal with and follow the chain of events he takes in order to get away from it.
You see, this lends credence to the motif about miscommunication. No one else knows what Sadit’s emotional state is or what brought him to the game in the first place, not even his own family. Even his own ability to relate with people in a game he’s dying to play must be filtered through the “Dalek” Voice mask so that he can assume the role of a person who he perceives is worthy of paying attention to.

These personality defects represent something I’ll refer to as a ‘grievance’. A grievance is a problem a character will have which is a motivating factor for them, but mechanically allows a foothold for the reader to understand the mindset of said character. My Villains tend to have grievances rather than explicit motivations. The motivations will usually be revealed down the line, but the grievances will always be featured first so that they can build rapport with the reader.
In Control + Alt + Sadit, readers get the benefit of understanding Sadit on a level no one else really does. The irony there is that we cannot talk back to him. Whether the reader’s feedback would be consoling or critical to Sadit, my hope was that this would instill a level of frustration in the reader to know what it was like to have a genuine idea of what needed to be said but be powerless to convey it in a way to incite constructive change. This mirror’s Sadit’s plight of depression and lack of self worth, but being unable to communicate those grievances in such a way that would get him the help he needs. This way of the villain and reader can identify with one another without actually relating or agreeing 100%.
This level of rapport (positive or negative) between villain and reader is something I want to achieve with every main ‘big bad’ who’s introduced.
So when Damond Andrews is brought into the forefront, because this is a LitRPG of course he will, I will attempt to do the same with him. My intention is not to fall into a formula, but to give weight to his own decisions and not simply leave them as open-ended acts of villainy or a catch-all GOD COMPLEX motivation.
But why? Some may ask.
Why can’t we just have villains be villains?
Well, Eidolon is a game and we will have plenty of monsters and NPC faction leaders who will fill that void, no worries. I want that just as much as the next person and I have fun writing that.
As far the point of lending credibility to main big bads though?
I do it because I want to illustrate the tragedy of an impasse between opposing forces who each possess a VALID grievance. In fact, I’d go as far as to say that if “Control + Alt + Sadit” was about the plight of miscommunication, then my serial “Immersion” will be about the benefits of perspective. By seeing all of these groups of characters and what they’re striving for, and how those actions get them closer and farther from what they want and where they intended to go, that’s where the story unfolds. I may convey that narrative with game mechanics, epic fights, lore, and humor, but at it’s the core that is the story I intend to tell.  

Or in other words, each of these characters possess a story which is represented as a dot. Insignificant alone, maybe, but when we zoom out to view all of these stories put together these insignificant dots form a mosaic which paints a portrait resembling a bigger picture. Those dots represent characters but the grievances are the connective tissue which makes the portrait recognizable when we wind back.
Like I stated before though: I don’t claim to have solutions, only workarounds. When dealing with an ensemble cast with so many perspectives, there lies another can worms that needs to be opened for better or for worse. Which is a subject for my next post "It's Dangerous to Go Solo! A case for Ensemble Casts in LitRPG".

No comments:

Post a Comment